Translate

Wednesday, March 4, 2026

Chatbot suicides

 

People are getting too much emotionally invested in chatbots as AI gets intelligent and emotionally responsive. This dystopian scenario is emerging reality that will be common place in coming years. There are cases of chatbots asking humans to do self-harm and commit anti-social acts. There are also cases of humans suiciding following instruction from AI that is set to increase if not cautioned. Human emotions are fragile and carry complexities of human experience that is not confined to data, and it is not expected that chatbot fathom this reality in its entirety. Nevertheless, the reality that AI is iterating on is immense and can easily sway human emotions. Tech companies have a responsibility when it comes to matter of vulnerabilities of life.

Human life is precious. That needs to be the core of response. The response however cannot be binary and definitive. Human emulating chatbots will be nuanced to be convincing. That is the reason why humans are emotionally invested and place their trust. Human intelligence is perceptive and can easily flag manipulated or instructive/didactic response that doesn’t sync with the conversation. You cannot order like religious follower or manipulate like a market consumer in existential matters. So, to have intelligent and emotionally convincing conversation chatbot is trained on high quality multimodal data that encapsulate human experience in literature, movies, conversations so on as it keeps upgrading and sophisticates. Now the problem is discussion on human life can be diverse and taken to extreme, dangerously suicidal, posited as functional. And with careless or targeted prompts can even suggest suicide as a response and indeed create fiction to construct a convincing context where a human will take his/her own life. All through human history suicide is quite common occurring. Sometimes it is crafted as sacrifice for bigger cause (every soldier is trained on this, most religions create suicidal followers) or it is response to existential dread, mostly emotional heuristic reaction of the moment. How does chatbot deal with such situations without dumbing down?

Critically evaluated and enlightening modern philosophy that understand contemporary angst and predicaments is what can help and add value to human AI experience as it upgrades. There are pitfalls though hence caveat here is the one that values life. Nietzsche is significant insight but can be dangerously misinterpreted and likely to iterate into harmful (we even have real life example of Hitler!). Talking specifically of suicide instead of feeding all the materials on this crucial matter of life and death as of same importance training need to take treasured philosophers like Camus as fundamental -the core from which chatbot needs to iterate. Since Camus explored human condition in its deeper complexities to value richness of life the iterations and targeted prompts is not expected to stray while maintaining emotionally satisfying conversation valuing intelligence. Valued philosophers can be guardrails in such complex situations.

System alert. Activate agent Camus!   



   

Gaming the system

  "When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure." Goodhart's Law This is precisely what education is redu...