Translate

Tuesday, January 6, 2026

Naked vulgarism of self-perpetuating extractive system

 With optimizing technologies, increasing per capita demands and ever-increasing human population the world is changing at faster pace than ever before. Since the framework of development is extractive and wanton consumption normalized as progress the world is increasingly edging collapse. It has severely stressed institutions of collective responsibility and individual care. Scaffoldings are snapping at an alarming rate. It seems we are on the course for a perfect storm that will have debilitating impact on majority of people and life on earth. This has not happened suddenly but is culmination of value system nurtured for decades. What was once morphed in liberal sounding democracy affirming play of words, while they hid their real sinister intentions in semantics of concern and sophisticated posturing, is now naked vulgarism of transactional system.  

While herd get stupider, and simultaneously fortuitously find themselves empowered through latest technologies, their increasing grouse fall for fantastical claims orchestrated by charlatans who get elected as leaders. As their number keeps increasing genuinely distressed common people too gravitate towards these narrowing options as it atleast seems -in their estimation through limited means, concerned about them in the increasingly insular world. Meanwhile sinister forces posing for higher morals aim for ridiculous to position their arrogant entitled selves as they weaken rule of law (and even common sense) and social contract of collective responsibility by encouraging worst in the name of democracy. They use humanist concerns to undermine local population -the majority gets increasingly marginalized; this gets exaggerated in social media. Any dilution of rule of law is weakening of scaffoldings of democratic society. It is the norms of interaction that bind into laws. Humanist concerns cannot be taken to ridiculous to not only undermine rule of law but severely degrade society through regressive consolidation that instigates revivalist xenophobic forces to augur worst primal instincts in humans and create fertile ground for herd to unleash. These severely restricts liberal space and threaten liberty and freedom. Any society will value and immensely gain from migrants (refugees are different matter) who add value -who are professionally skilled and carry progressive value, and assimilate to a welcoming culture with a sense of gratitude and enthusiasm to learn and capitalize on this opportunity to grow as a human. This brings genuine diversity and valuable addition to progressive society. What we have seen in the last many decades is mostly vandalism on welcoming societies and simultaneous exaggerated spread in social media. With weakening of rule of law -assertion of liberty and liberal values, to appear humanist the worst of humanity are empowered; the backlash is being sinisterly capitalized. These opportunists pose in left or right spectrum of deal depending on proximity of gravy and intensity of their gargantuan crave for power and influence that seems to be defining characteristic of transactional value system. What is seen at local level very soon find expressions at international level. Trump is no accident. He is carefully nurtured by forces that are severely denting progressive values for decades. There are little Trumps all across the world nurtured as successful by extractive system. The vulgar and uncouth is an everyday expression that is monetized and now urgently weaponized for bigger role. Much of the world is not shocked by the development in Caracas. We smirk in disgust and feel defeated in every possible way.  

Trump is a vulgar extension of what was already dormant. While there are oppositions in US and you can very well see through their hypocrisy. To begin with recall the amazing lackadaisical attitude of Democrats when dire predictions of Trump election was apparent. Meanwhile comedians in US play a significant role in ridiculing the powerful (and this couch potato semiliterate is particularly sensitive to TV show image ratings and easily miffed) until you realize it is mostly against individuals and not powerful systems that nurture these since they too are complicit and gain by playing along (one influential standup comedian mentions these times as “bit of wobble”, while in an amazing lack of awareness of foundational ideas of US, affirming for british monarchy!). Criticism of the system if ever is mild, in an apologetic tone so as to not ruffle feathers of deep state. Entertainment is a big part of American idea of democracy, as consolidation of narration of free society with free choices orchestrated by corporates that is now a template in most part of the world. It has all become a show while harsh reality gets delegated to people. Charismatic Reagan was a pawn of neoliberal capitalism who eased into his role as a best actor. Don’t forget Trump too learned his tricks in entertainment industry. There is nothing in what Trump is doing is not extension of what was already dormant and executed with finesse by political actors over the years. If Bush was stupid and not entirely dislikeable Trump is vulgar and hated. They are puppets extending the need of the deep state that is very clearly oil rich oligarch control. Trump is belligerent and arrogant in a way that shows acute awareness of smallness of his being hence easily controlled.

As progressive societies reel under weakening of rule of law, ostentatiously as accommodating the barbarian other to vitiate liberal space, the onslaught of revivalist regressive is persistent. The damage is severe and has repercussions across the world where nascent democracies that try to institutionalize progressive values face tribulations for egalitarian claims. Elois in West have severely damaged the world by their irresponsible entitled ways and made it difficult to assert humanist concerns. When might is deemed right brutal brazen acts undermine international laws and civilized consensus, it is a severe jolt to the scaffoldings that keep the world together. These are deep fissures of vulgar transactional values that define everyday into fracture of such scale. When Bush (and Blair -the torchbearer of britishery) undermined the international law more than two decades back they unleashed mayhem and misery and faced no consequences whatsoever for their breach of humanity. Self-assured vulgar Trump clearly stated that it is about oil, indeed “our oil”. Imperialistic exploitative forces and ideas that sustains this impunity were not dismantled (as is the cases with feudal institutions) but were kept active in morphed semantics and insidiously dormant in thriving ideas. Also note, by undermining and humiliating Maria Machado (her own character trait is shockingly embarrassing) Trump doesn’t seem to be bothered about reinstating democracy in Venezuela. This is flagrant attempt to convert Venezuela into vassal state so as to capture oil reserves, he has weaponized rogue power into international relations. By blatantly undermining international law he has emboldened worst from across the world and pushed the world into increasingly perilous situation.  

It is also not surprising that West which overuses semantics of humanism and egalitarian values to impress is deeply divided over this serious breach of international law and civilized consensus. They recognize opportunist material concerns and transactional advantage. This is how it is. And then we look towards these in expectation of cooperation to address urgent global challenges. Be worried people. Be very worried. The system has failed us as it continues to self-perpetuate despite worst possibilities for humanity. Meanwhile think about this: Isn’t it possible for even an LLM based AI to effortlessly replicate this template of self-preserving self-perpetuating extractive system at the peril of humanity?

*I had bit of argument with chatbot on the usage of ‘barbarian other’. Chatbot found it highly objectionable in the light of historical context of the word and its usage, arguing subjectiveness of civilization. I found this line of argument contentious. This obscuring contemporary concern into traps of history I find objectionable. Word has to define what it is meant to define. In the contemporary context anyone or anything that stands against values of liberty and freedom is barbaric. Not recognizing this is dilution of human progress and a detestable patronizing position that undermines common people’s aspiration for elitist concerns.                     

Gaming the system

  "When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure." Goodhart's Law This is precisely what education is redu...